Whole house water filter installation in a basement

Water Softener vs. Water Filter: Making the Right Choice for Your Home


For many homeowners and businesses, the quest for clean, pure water is a top priority. Both water softeners and water filters play a pivotal role in ensuring water quality. However, understanding their differences and functionalities can be a challenge. In this guide, we will delve deeper into the intricacies of water softeners and water filters, comparing three popular products to help you make an informed decision.

Understanding the Basics: Water Softeners vs Water Filters

What is a Water Softener?

A water softener is a system designed to combat hard water. Hard water contains minerals like calcium and magnesium, which can cause scale buildup in pipes and appliances. A water softener works by exchanging these hard minerals with sodium ions, thus "softening" the water.


  • Extends the life of appliances by preventing scale buildup.
  • Improves the efficiency of soaps and detergents.
  • Can lead to smoother skin and softer hair.


  • Requires regular maintenance and salt replenishment.
  • Not designed to remove other contaminants.

What is a Water Filter?

A water filter, on the other hand, targets a broader range of contaminants. These can include chlorine, sediment, harmful chemicals, and even certain microorganisms. Water filters use various mechanisms, such as activated carbon or reverse osmosis, to purify water.


  • Removes a wide range of contaminants.
  • Improves taste and odor of water.
  • Can lead to better overall health.


  • Might not address water hardness.
  • Requires periodic filter replacements.

BB20-P Pelican Water Filters

The BB20-P Pelican Water Filters

The BB20-P Pelican Water Filters from Water Filter Direct is a high-capacity, whole house water filter system. It's designed to remove sediment, chlorine, and other contaminants from your water supply. The system boasts a 20,000-gallon filter capacity and features a pressure release button for easy filter changes.


    • High-capacity system suitable for large households.
    • Reduces chlorine, sediment, and other contaminants.
    • Easy maintenance with pressure release feature.


    • Does not address water hardness.
    • Filter replacements might be frequent for larger households.

    Hansing Whole House Water Softener System

    Hansing Whole House Water Softener System

    The Hansing Whole House Water Softener System on Amazon is a salt-free water softener that uses a unique technology to soften water without the use of chemicals or salt. It's designed to reduce scale, improve skin and hair health, and extend the life of appliances. The system has a capacity of 280,000 grains and can serve a household of 2-6 people.


      • Chemical-free and salt-free operation.
      • Reduces scale and improves appliance lifespan.
      • Suitable for medium-sized households.


      • Might not be ideal for very large households or commercial settings.
      • Does not remove other contaminants like chlorine.

      iSpring WDS80K Whole House Water Filter

      iSpring WDS80K Anti-Scale Whole House Water Filter

      The iSpring WDS80K Whole House Water Filter on Amazon is a dual-purpose system that both filters and softens water. It uses a combination of KDF and activated carbon to remove a wide range of contaminants, while also reducing the hardness of water. The system has a capacity of 80,000 grains and features a digital display for easy monitoring.


        • Dual functionality addresses both hardness and contaminants.
        • High capacity suitable for most households.
        • Digital display aids in maintenance and monitoring.


        • Might require more maintenance than standalone systems.
        • Initial setup might be more complex.

        Conclusion: Making the Right Choice

        Choosing between a water softener and a water filter largely depends on your specific water concerns. If hard water is causing issues in your home, a dedicated water softener like the Hansing system might be ideal. However, if you're more concerned about contaminants affecting your health and the taste of your water, the BB20-P Pelican Water Filter could be the solution. For those seeking a comprehensive approach, the iSpring WDS80K offers the best of both worlds.

        Remember, investing in water quality is an investment in health, longevity of appliances, and overall well-being. By understanding the nuances of water treatment systems, you can ensure a safer and more enjoyable water experience for all.

        Featured Image by senivpetro

        Back to blog

        Related Articles